Where Will They NOT Sell Advertising?



USAToday is reporting on a high school teacher in San Diego, who has started selling advertisements on his test papers in order to pay for printing costs for his class. He felt it was the only way to subsidize the costs of printing for his classroom; his budget is $300, but his printing costs about $500 per school year.

Most ads, at this point, are pretty innocuous. Inspirational messages from parents top the list of ads, but ads have also been bought by local engineering firms and an orthodontist.

What concerns me about this is that this marketing gives advertisers access to children. Our children are the most vulnerable to advertising, without the maturity and life experience to weed out the obnoxiousness that is advertising. I can block advertising when my kids surf (ad blocker plus for Firefox) and keep the television watching to a minimum, but if my kids are getting advertising at school on their tests and homework papers, I have absolutely no control over that. While I would trust that the teacher would not allow questionable advertising to be printed on his test papers, when it comes to the almighty dollar, often greed trumps good sense.

I can appreciate the teacher’s ingenuity, but I think there is probably a better way. If he only needs to make $200, couldn’t he have had a small class fundraiser that targeted the parents, who should be supporting their kids’ education anyway? I have to think this teacher went too far.


GNC-2008-12-02 #428 The HP Magic Giveaway



I talk about the HP Magic Givaway and the concerns I have about what Ustream is doing at the beginning of the show along with a host of other things. Do not forget the People’s Choice Podcast Awards Ceremony

Please Support my Show Sponsors!:
[Save 10% off on any order at GoDaddy.com!] Use Code Todd
[Try GoToMeeting free for 30 days at GoToMeeting.com/techpodcasts. No credit card needed.]

Twitter Me http://www.twitter.com/geeknews
My Facebook Profile
FriendFeed GNC Room!!
Comments to 619-342-7365 e-mail to geeknews@gmail.com

Listener Links:
Pownce Dead Pool
Surgeons Weld Wounds
Square Trade
Don’t Spam Facebook
NASA Tool Bag in Orbit

Show Notes:
Bad RSS
Time Machine Nightmare
Vista SP2 in April 09
Pownce Acquired by Six Apart
Antivirus Definition Lag
Firefox to 20%
Mac to 8.8%
Play Poker Online be Swindled
Soviet UFO Disclosures
Sandisk and SSD Improvements at CES
Media Point Device and Blockbuster
Nokia Big Announce
LHC could be offline to 2010
Apple Tells Mac Users Get Antivirus Software
Clearwire + Xohm = Clearwire
Electronic Standby Mode
Do you read TOS?
Cheaper – Higher Resolution Cameras from Mistake

BLOCKBUSTER Total Access click to activate coupon for $10 off your first month.


Ustream.tv removing critical comments in Messsage Forum



Yesterday after seeing ads injected into my video stream I asked the question in the Ustream.TV forum if there was a way to shut the ads off. The reply was no. The moderator then closed the message topic from further comment.

Seeing he closed the message topic I posted a second message that outlined my concerns and hoped to get a constructive conversation going. Well they not only closed that discussion before anyone could respond they actually deleted the comment in order to stifle debate. This was a second slap in the face.

The question that needs to be asked does Ustream.TV want to have a conversation with it’s family of content contributors on their own site or do they want to have the conversation here?

I find it very curious in over 2 hours of viewing shows that are featured on the main page of Ustream.TV that none of those shows has the advertising we saw yesterday popping up. But as you dig in deeper, and leave the front page the advertising is very apparent.

What it appears they are doing, is making the shows on the front page look inviting without the intrusive advertising, and then sticking advertising into the content producers streams that are not on the front page of the website. Good strategy if you do not want to scare off perspective new content producers.

I have received a Twitter from someone at Ustream saying they would like to do a call. I will talk with them but they need to understand that they need to start being a bit more transparent and be willing to take the heat of criticism in their own forums. More as this develops.

To be fair I found out that Mogulus has started doing the same type of ad injection as well. Which really disappoints me that neither of these two sites informed their content producers or have given us a pro-offering that we could pay to play without advertising.


Ustream.TV pushing inline ads without warning.



Revised:

I am leaving Usream.TV as soon as possible. Large in part due to what happened during a live sponsored event on ustream when they started without warning pushing large advertisements into the content stream.

I did not opt into having ads jammed into my viewers face. It was ridiculous. The ads where completely inappropriate for our audience.

I would have gladly payed for a premium service to not have ads forced n my viewers. But now that they have done this without warning I am finished with them they have burned a bridge here.

This could not come at a worse time as I was planning on holding the Podcast Awards ceremony on their service. I will be looking at alternatives today and tomorrow. Mogulus is one possibility but their encoding is not as good as Ustream.

The way they initiated this is wrong. No warning nothing. I understand a company has to make money just give us a heads up that this is going to start. 

Sad to think that they would not consider asking people to pay for premium accounts before doing this.

Not only that but the moderator over on their forums closed the discussion when I asked to how to turn advertising off, apparently they are getting some heat over this.

I have been chatting with some of their biggest streamed shows and they are pulling the plug on them as well.

Update: It should be noted that I am not against a company making money after all they have to keep the lights on. What I do take issue with is that the ads that are being pushed into the streaming content multiple times over the course of a hour and taking up nearly 1/2 of the screen real estate. The ads popped up so many times in that the viewers where annoyed. When the viewers get annoyed they leave.

When Blip.TV came out with a pro service I gladly payed the $100.00 a year for faster encoding and the ability to have my own branded player without a watermark. They got paid and I got some cool new features. I am sure Ustream.TV is having trouble determining what is a fair value to charge for a pro-service but for many of us our viewer experience if important enough to pay for. If I were a betting man I bet the ads in those overlays do not pay that much. I bet what i would be willing to pay is more than they would ever make in this type of advertising.


HP Magic Giveaway First Week of Contest Launches



2008hpmagic2

Hey folks here is the first weeks worth of Contest Launch Dates and Awards Announcements. Each participating blog in the HP Magic Giveaway has it’s own Contest Launch Date and Award date. That way your not trying to do the contest in all 50 participating sites at once.

URLContest LaunchAward Announcement
Bleeping Computer28-Nov04-Dec
Gear Live
Windows Connected
Morningside Mom29-Nov05-Dec
Thoughts on poetics & tech
MediaBlab30-Nov06-Dec
Neowin
BostonPocketPC
HackCollege01-Dec07-Dec
The Gadgeteer02-Dec08-Dec
Gotta Be Mobile
I Started Something
Down-to-Earth Mama03-Dec09-Dec
moosh in indy.
La Bitácora de Erwin Ried
Carlos Alberto
Geeks To Go!04-Dec10-Dec
GearDiary
Geeks!
One Day, One Job05-Dec11-Dec

I will talk about this sites contest launch date during my next podcast released on Tuesday!


November Tech Podcasts Network Round Table



Announcing the Nov Tech Podcast Round Table
Saturday November 29th
4pm Eastern 1pm Pacific

We have three presentations. That should be worthy of everyone’s time.

Rob Greenlee from Zune to talk about the Zune and Podcasting Support
Andy McCaskey with a variety of Topics
Todd Cochrane to share his Live Podcast Setup

Should be a fun event and hope that you will join us for the live event.

To participate in the Round Table is very simple, 15 Minutes before we start Simply Click this link.

GotoMeeting will load automatically and then you can then choose to either dial in, or participate with a headset via VOIP. Mac users will want to tune in as well because my demo of GotoMetting will be done with a Mac. GotoMeeting Version 4 has 100% Mac Support as well as PC Support.

GotoMeeting is the official sponsor of the Tech Podcasts Round Table you can get a free no credit card required trial at www.gotomeeting.com/techpodcasts