When I signed up for DirecTV back in 2004 I received the, now legendary, DirecTiVo (the Samsung S4040R). I loved it. I almost cried in late 2007 when I bought my first HDTV and “had” to give it up for a DirecTV HD DVR. Time marches on, though, and DirecTV and TiVo were no longer partners.
TiVo joined forces with DirecTV in early 2002 with units made by Phillips, Hughes, and Sony. Later RCA and Samsung joined in. Then in late 2006, when NewsCorp gained control of DirecTV, They phased out TiVo in favor of another NewsCorp company, NDS, which was already manufacturing DVR’s for the European market.
In late 2008, with NewsCorp out of the picture, DirecTV again announced a partnership with TiVo. And, since then, we have waited….and waited….and waited. Delay after delay has been announced. It’s really gotten to the point where DirecTV subscribers are starting to think of it as gamers think of Duke Nukem Forever!
The latest release, which was scheduled for late 2010, has apparently been pushed to early 2011. Rumors persist that beta units are floating around, but I know of nobody who has received one and requests to DirecTV are denied.
So, is this the ultimate Vaporware? For that matter, after reading reviews of the new TiVo Premiere, do users really want it? The current DirecTV HD DVR (the HR23-700) has a 500GB hard drive, which is more than most other DVR’s issued by cable and satellite providers. The software (interface) isn’t that bad either. I am starting to think that TiVo, as much as we all pull for them, are verging on extinction. They seriously need to get their Comcast and DirecTV boxes out the door yesterday before the battle is completely lost.
TiVo has made what I consider a strategic blunder in announcing their new subscription plans. If new subscribers are not willing to sign a three year subscription fee the monthly charge for the service is going to be $19.95 per month. Let me see I have a HD-DVR from my cable provider that cost me $9.95 per month why would I want to pay $19.95 per month on a device that will likely be obsolete in two years. Someone at TiVo did not in my opinion think this through; no educated consumer would sign a three year contract that has a $150.00 early cancellation fee.
Sorry No TiVo for me. [www.zatznotfunny.com]
A TiVo Series Three Receiver was on my shopping list for this Christmas season. I have been watching the reviews of the unit and the new C|Net review of the Series III that I saw today makes me wonder if I should take the unit off my wish list.
We all have learned to hate DRM, and we all hate devices that are overzealous in enforcing DRM. It seems TiVo has got DRM fever and is running scared from the studio’s. Additionally I am not real happy with devices that make you revert to old school techniques to archive programming. Check out these two depressing quotes from the review.
“the only way to archive your TiVo Series3 recordings is the old-fashioned way: dump them to a video recorder in real time.”
“Once again, though, overzealous copy protection has taken something simple and turned it into a Sisyphean ordeal. All we wanted to do was watch TV, and connect our gear with a minimum of cables and wires. Thanks to DRM, that simple task becomes more difficult all the time.”
Once you read the linked review and determin where they had specific hardware connectivity issues you may be inclined as I am to not to move forward with a purchase of this unit. I have said it once and I will say it again because it is worth repeating. The manufactures and their willingness to roll over on consumers will be the ultimate demise of fair use. They will wait till our legacy systems wear out and then kill functionality with new products.
It is obvious that DRM is halting innovation and the ability to re-utilize media that is legally yours to record and enjoy. [Cnet.com]
Well I have some information on TiVo that many of you are not going to be happy about. TiVo is picking the content that they want they have a editorial team that picks what gets listed. I have it on pretty good authority that the format has to be short, absolutely child safe, produced on a consistent basis and much be as near broadcast quality as possible. I understand the need for a child safe format on their network, not good to have mom come home and have the kids getting a earful of adult material.
I am not sure I agree with their strategy in the way subscribers can manually add a show as the interface is beyond painful. They live and die by the ease of use of their interface but if you have a TiVo try entering your Podcast URL. Their is no way to supply a single click subscription button to get your show added to the device from a remote website.
The platform is very closed at this point and hopefully they will listen to the community and open up and make it easier for us to get our shows manually added to a device subscription list, for all of our TiVo listeners and readers. If you work at TiVo and would like to collaborate on a way to make it easier for the rest of the community to allow people to one click subscribe to our shows please drop me a line firstname.lastname@example.org
It’s pretty obvious that TiVo did not put a lot of thought into their roll out of podcasting support. TiVo you blew it you should have reached out to podcasters and let them give you some input you have missed a golden opportunity here. You can save face by reaching out to the community and asking for some help. You should have came to leading podcasters made them sign a NDA and asked for our guidance in the first place. Let’s talk. [Mike's Information Technology Blog]
Wait until my kids find out about this?
Nintendo fans: Tired of your PSP-totin buddies giving you grief for not having multimedia on your gaming handheld of choice? Well fret no more, because Nintendo has rebranded their Play-Yan multimedia device for the Gameboy Micro.
Read the full story here.]
I can hear some of you screaming already. It appears TiVo is incorporating DRM into this version of software. Meaning broadcasters will likely be able to flag content and then you will not be able to record it on your TiVo DVR!
Some comments from the referenced site that I agree with
“Tivo 1: Just because someone asks for a feature, there is no reason to give it to them.”
“Tivo 2: Better treat your subscribers well, or you won
I have been waiting for an excuse to dump the DVR we have from the cable company. If TiVo launches this movie download service by the end of the year this would synch the deal. [Engadget]