In a little bit of a UK scoop, the folks at Buffalo lent GNC three of their latest wireless “n” products for a first review. The three AirStation devices were announced and covered by GNC back in October, so we’ll skip the usual pleasantries and get down to business.
First up, was the AirStation N-Technology USB2 adapter (WLI-UC-GNM) which is as small as it looks in the picture. Installation is very straightforward – run the installation CD first to install the drivers, pop the adapter into a spare USB port and job done. I was able to connect to an existing 11g network and the 11n network without any problems at all. There’s also a little application installed which allows selection between the 20 MHz and 40 MHz bandwidths which equates to the 75 Mb/s and 150 Mb/s settings. There’s more on the real-world data transfer rates later.
Next was the AirStation N-Technology 150 Mb/s router (WCR-GN). This is actually smaller in real life than the picture would suggest, being only 11 cm high, excluding the aerial. After connecting the router to the network via an ethernet cable, the installation program allows the user to choose from two different possible scenarios – router or bridge. Once selected, the installation program finds the router and configures it. The user is asked to set a device password and to give the device an IP address. Although a configuration program is included, I found it easiest to use the router’s web interface to set things up.
The configuration for the wireless side was pretty impressive, with support for multiple SSIDs, including one that was passed directly out over the WAN and was unable to access the LAN. This caters for legacy devices such as media streamers or games consoles that only support unsecure WEP.
The WCR-GN supports WPS and AOSS, Buffalo’s equivalent. Frankly, I could never get the AOSS pairing to work. It’s so little effort to put in an encryption key, I’ve no idea why anyone bothers with these user-friendly time savers, because they never are and never do.
To give the 11n devices a proper evaluation, I carried out some data transfer rate testing using LAN Speed Test for TotuSoft. The table below gives the nominal and measured data rates for different connection types.
|Connection||Nominal Data Rate||Measured Data Rate|
|LAN||100 Mb/s||65 Mb/s|
|11g||54 Mb/s||20 Mb/s|
|11n @ 20 MHz||75 Mb/s||34 Mb/s|
|11n @ 40 MHz||150 Mb/s||44 Mb/s|
Bear in mind that with all the encryption on the wireless transmissions, the measured data rate will be much lower than the nominal data rate. These figures are broadly in line with other data rates reported on the Internet. HD video requires a minimum sustained data rate around 25 Mb/s, so it looks to me that the 11n data rates are good. Microsoft have an article on HD formats which is worth a read.
Finally, I got out the Nfiniti Dual-Band Wireless-N Ethernet Converter (WLAE-AG300N). I was most interested in this as it promised to be convertible between an access point, extender and bridge, and a full 300Mb/s device. The Converter has two ethernet ports meaning that things like Bluray players and IP TVs can connect through the bridge back to the Internet.
As before, the installation was a breeze and in the first instance, I set up the Converter as an access point. This worked great and I was able to get data throughput in the 44Mb/s range. Remember that although this was a 300Mb/s device, the USB adapter on the laptop was only a 150Mb/s device so the data rate was limited by the USB adapter.
Setting the WLAE-AG300N as a bridge back to the WCR-GN Router was less successful. Although I was able to get the two devices to connect, I was never able to establish a 11n level connection; it only connected as if it were an 11g network and throughput was around 20 Mb/s. I worked with Buffalo’s tech support to try and get a resolution but it wasn’t sorted by the time I returned the device.
Overall, the USB2 adapter and the 150Mb/s router worked well and I think they’re good value for money at RRPs of £19.99 and £29.99 respectively. Judgement is reserved regarding the Ethernet Converter (£39.99) as it worked well as an access point but the bridging was poor. If you were only setting up a 150Mb/s network, a pair of WCR-GN routers would actually be a cheaper way of establishing a connection from ethernet-only devices.
Thanks to Buffalo for the loan.