Geek News: Latest Technology, Product Reviews, Gadgets and Tech Podcast News for Geeks

MagicJack: Helping our family talk for cheap!

Posted by GNC at 2:13 PM on June 17, 2009

About 16 months ago I was visiting family and the TV was left on an infomercial for some reason.  An infomercial about free the internet telephone MagicJack was airing.  They would walk into a business and give them a USB MagicJack for free and ask them to try it. Of course all of the reviews were great.  I turned the channel.  Just another commercial.

And then my sister who works abroad in India called me.  She told me that she was calling from India on a MagicJack with a US phone number.  For free.  We had done everything in talking with her in India.  Skype, calling cards, you name it.  Skype was shaky due to low magicjackbandwidth.  Normal phone lines often had a delay of two seconds.  That led to some humorous attempts at communication.  Our normal fallback was Yahoo messenger.  And then this MagicJack.  The call was crisper than the phone but with only a millisecond of delay.  The land-line phone would drop the call one out of every 4 or 5.  MagicJack has dropped maybe twice in thirty calls.  And the price?  $47 for the USB device and one year of long distance.  Wow.  Currently you can upgrade to 5 years for $60.  So I signed up for the free trial.  I am getting ready to work abroad myself so having a US number anywhere in the world would be great, and the ability for friends and business clients to call a US number would be invaluable.

Pros:

  1. Sleek packaging with simple plug-n-play install.  I did have to unplug and re-plug it in one time before it installed properly.  The initial registration and number selection was very easy.
  2. Initial calls from the US to the US were very clear and the people could not tell I was on a web phone. One of the ten calls seemed to have a slight delay and scratch to it.  I should note that I was using a slow DSL connection of less than 756kb down and 512kb up.
  3. Call forwarding works great (Spoiler/Con: Must login to web interface to set the forwarding number. These options would be better placed in the desktop client).
  4. Option to purchase international calling credits. Would allow you to forward to a foreign number cell phone.
  5. Allows me to use any phone. I currently have a $15 cordless phone plugged in and it works great.  Simply plugged the standard phone cord into the usb jack and into the phone.  That simple.  Can use either the phone or computer interface to make the call.
  6. Two voicemail options. Normal voicemail that picks up if the computer is unplugged or you do not answer (no ability to set the number of rings before pickup).  The second voicemail and message option picks up if you are on another call.
  7. Email voicemail works well. Today I received two emails with an attached .wav file.  They stated the phone number who left the message, and how long the message was.  Worked flawlessly.

Cons:

  1. Computer must be on for the phone to ring.
  2. Phone interface on the computer has ads and could use an interface lift.
  3. Contacts feature on the phone does not import from Outlook or Address Book that I can see.
  4. Very limited website interface.  Poorly documented support section.
  5. Poor reviews of their customer service seem to be plentiful.
  6. Read complaints of dropped calls and or calls that do not ring through. Not enough people know of my number to have tested this.

Conclusion:

For me this appears to be a viable and very cheap option.  I have some reservation about the longevity and future development of the product.  Hopefully it moves beyond a shopping network and pitchman item.  For now it is going to keep me within my cell phone calling plan and help me transition to global traveling.  And I am so excited about the possibilities once Google Voice is out for public use!  I missed getting in on that by one day when Grand Central was purchased by Google.  Until then I am going to be a MagicJack user.

10 Comments

  1. From Urlreviews at 12:14 pm on June 18, 2009

    MJ is not working for me, the quality here is horrible and I had to drop it after a few months.

  2. From YukiEiri at 2:50 pm on June 18, 2009

    I have one of these also. I’m in California and it works flawlessly. One call has been dropped, but I was calling a person that was in a remote area of Arizona on her cell, so I’m not sure if it was the MagicJack or her phone that dropped the call. All the pros are perfect. I have not found a way to import contacts from Outlook either, and that would be an EXTREMELY convenient feature for MagicJack to look at in a future upgrade. I bought this after my T-mobile cell phone bill reached $700 last month. $20/year sure beats 10x that per month on T-mobile!

  3. From Nolan at 4:23 pm on June 18, 2009

    The quality will no doubt vary for people. I would assume it is tied to the internet connection more than the MJ itself. I forgot to note that on the slower DSL speed it cut out a bit if I tried surfing the net at the same time. As I said earlier it works from India to the US on a internet connection over there that can be very shaky. I did also try it from my MJ to the India MJ and the quality was equally as impressive.

  4. From Austoon Daily » MagicJack: Helping our family talk for cheap at 7:06 am on June 19, 2009

    [...] MagicJack: Helping our family talk for cheap [...]

  5. From Matthew at 12:43 pm on June 20, 2009

    FYI – Be advised that MagicJack has VERY LIMITED “area codes” secured. My father in Connecticut signed up for magic jack only to find out that they do not have any phone numbers available in his area code. This means his neighbors and friends have to call long distance and pay to call him!!

    Magic Jack has been telling him “soon, soon” for 18 months, when asked about a timeframe for getting numbers in his area code. I’m beginning to wonder if they even have plans to obtain those numbers.

    Buyer beware.

  6. From YukiEiri at 1:29 pm on June 20, 2009

    I should append my post to include something I just recently noticed today. If you doing something which involves high bandwidth (such as downloading a large torrent file) when you are trying to make a call, the call quality will suffer. I was downloading a 700MB torrent file today, and attempted to make a call and noticed dropouts during the conversation every 5 seconds or so. This, of course, made the call completely unlivable and non-communicative. Once I stopped the torrent download, everything was once again well and good.

  7. From adolfo umana at 5:46 pm on July 3, 2009

    Hi I want to know if I can instal fron costa rica to usa

  8. From sallyconnelly at 11:52 am on July 6, 2009

    i already have the magicjack but I tried to cancell my phone and they said you would have to call at&t for me to cancell my phone service and I also cancelled my att&t dsl internet I am with concast internet now.

  9. From Ron at 1:34 pm on July 8, 2009

    The MagicJack has worked great for me and my family for over a year now.

    The only problems I have had with it have been with my own internet connection and not really related to the ‘jack’ itself. However, this is rare.

    Great little device.

  10. From Nolan at 6:15 am on July 9, 2009

    Adolfo, you would need to purchase it from the USA with a USA phone number. I see no reason it would not work unless the initial activation needs to be done in the USA as well. If you have family here, have them purchase, activate, and send it to you.